Court Nixes FDA’s Approval of Genetically Engineered Salmon
It would be the first genetically modified animal intended for human consumption in the world.
A district court in California has rolled back the US Food and Drug Administration’s approval of a genetically modified salmon.
Back in 2015, the FDA declared that it had completed all its risk analysis on AquAdvantage, a genetically modified salmon-type fish. (It has some non-salmon genes.) The FDA further declared that this salmon was safe, thus becoming the first governmental agency, anywhere in the world, to approve a genetically modified animal for human consumption.
On Thursday, a district court in San Francisco ruled that the FDA had not, in fact, done adequate analysis to ensure that AquAdvantage is safe.
AquAdvantage salmon is a genetically modified Atlantic salmon; it has DNA from the Pacific king salmon as well as some DNA from a cold-water fish in the eelpout family, the latter of which is not closely related to salmon at all. These GMO salmon are created to grow incredibly fast, around twice as fast as unaltered Atlantic salmon.
Sounds potentially profitable, right? But nobody besides the FDA seemed to be convinced back in 2015 that AquAdvantage salmon was a good idea. Costco, Whole Foods, Trader Joe’s, Kroger’s, and other retailers fairly quickly stated that despite initial FDA permission, they would not be selling AquAdvantage salmon.
And in 2016, a coalition of environmental groups, fishermen’s unions, public safety organizations, and Native nations sued the FDA, claiming that the FDA had not done its due diligence in evaluating the possible environmental ramifications of this salmon’s approval. AquaBounty, the company behind AquAdvantage, says that its initial pens, which are on land, would not allow the salmon to escape into the wild, and that the AquAdvantage salmon are not likely to survive in the wild even if they do escape.
But the federal court in San Francisco ruled that the FDA had not properly researched what would happen if the AquAdvantage salmon did escape into the wild—regardless of how unlikely that scenario is, the FDA is still required to look into it. The FDA had said that this analysis did not fall under its purview; the court disagreed. And AquaBounty had already begun constructing more facilities for the GMO salmon, based on the approval from its first FDA ruling. Essentially, the court said: You guys don’t know enough. Go back and figure it out and we’ll look at it once you’re done.
The major environmental risk for a GMO product like the AquAdvantage salmon lies in what happens if the salmon escapes. Does it out-compete native Atlantic salmon, a protected species that’s classified as endangered in some places? Does it breed with native fish, causing further disruptions to the marine ecosystem? Does it devour some other species en masse? These are questions, the court says, that AquaBounty and the FDA need to adequately and safely answer.
Follow us
Republish!
Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.
Republish this article
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Want to republish a Modern Farmer story?
We are happy for Modern Farmer stories to be shared, and encourage you to republish our articles for your audience. When doing so, we ask that you follow these guidelines:
Please credit us and our writers
For the author byline, please use “Author Name, Modern Farmer.” At the top of our stories, if on the web, please include this text and link: “This story was originally published by Modern Farmer.”
Please make sure to include a link back to either our home page or the article URL.
At the bottom of the story, please include the following text:
“Modern Farmer is a nonprofit initiative dedicated to raising awareness and catalyzing action at the intersection of food, agriculture, and society. Read more at <link>Modern Farmer</link>.”
Use our widget
We’d like to be able to track our stories, so we ask that if you republish our content, you do so using our widget (located on the left hand side of the article). The HTML code has a built-in tracker that tells us the data and domain where the story was published, as well as view counts.
Check the image requirements
It’s your responsibility to confirm you're licensed to republish images in our articles. Some images, such as those from commercial providers, don't allow their images to be republished without permission or payment. Copyright terms are generally listed in the image caption and attribution. You are welcome to omit our images or substitute with your own. Charts and interactive graphics follow the same rules.
Don’t change too much. Or, ask us first.
Articles must be republished in their entirety. It’s okay to change references to time (“today” to “yesterday”) or location (“Iowa City, IA” to “here”). But please keep everything else the same.
If you feel strongly that a more material edit needs to be made, get in touch with us at [email protected]. We’re happy to discuss it with the original author, but we must have prior approval for changes before publication.
Special cases
-
Extracts. You may run the first few lines or paragraphs of the article and then say: “Read the full article at Modern Farmer” with a link back to the original article.
-
Quotes. You may quote authors provided you include a link back to the article URL.
-
Translations. These require writer approval. To inquire about translation of a Modern Farmer article, contact us at [email protected]
-
Signed consent / copyright release forms. These are not required, provided you are following these guidelines.
-
Print. Articles can be republished in print under these same rules, with the exception that you do not need to include the links.
Tag us
When sharing the story on social media, please tag us using the following: - Twitter (@ModFarm) - Facebook (@ModernFarmerMedia) - Instagram (@modfarm)
Use our content respectfully
Modern Farmer is a nonprofit and as such we share our content for free and in good faith in order to reach new audiences. Respectfully,
-
No selling ads against our stories. It’s okay to put our stories on pages with ads.
-
Don’t republish our material wholesale, or automatically; you need to select stories to be republished individually.
-
You have no rights to sell, license, syndicate, or otherwise represent yourself as the authorized owner of our material to any third parties. This means that you cannot actively publish or submit our work for syndication to third party platforms or apps like Apple News or Google News. We understand that publishers cannot fully control when certain third parties automatically summarize or crawl content from publishers’ own sites.
Keep in touch
We want to hear from you if you love Modern Farmer content, have a collaboration idea, or anything else to share. As a nonprofit outlet, we work in service of our community and are always open to comments, feedback, and ideas. Contact us at [email protected].Court Nixes FDA’s Approval of Genetically Engineered Salmon
by Dan Nosowitz, Modern Farmer
November 5, 2020
Modern Farmer Weekly
Solutions Hub
Innovations, ideas and inspiration. Actionable solutions for a resilient food system.
ExploreShare With Us
We want to hear from Modern Farmer readers who have thoughtful commentary, actionable solutions, or helpful ideas to share.
Submit
I don’t know, looks to me like they addressed the questions. I guess they could define the phrase “effectively sterile” (the answer is in the FAQ “What is Triploidy?” farther down the page, but it could be linked). The farms aren’t just inland, but *indoors* as well. Specifically, the FDA asked the following four questions What is the likelihood that AquAdvantage Salmon will escape the conditions of confinement? What is the likelihood that AquAdvantage Salmon will survive and disperse if they escape the conditions of confinement? What is the likelihood that AquAdvantage Salmon will reproduce and establish if they escape… Read more »
Disgraceful.
If I wanted to eat eel, I’d buy eel…
GMO causes health problems. My horse got respiratory issues, my vet said ‘it will only get worse’. I changed him to non-gmo oats from Canada – he was cured. Learn the lesson, folks. I only eat non-gmo and organic. We are what we eat.