The McClintic Wildlife Management Area is over 3,000 acres of woodland, farms, and wetland in Point Pleasant, West Virginia, population 4,350. In the dense forest you’ll find animals, hunters, partying teenagers, and the occasional explosive bunker. Locals call McClintic the “TNT Area” because the grounds were once used for munitions manufacturing in World War II. The explosives were stored in bunkers covered in sod, and their humps still mar the landscape of the TNT Area. Occasionally, they blow up. But it’s not a careless hunter or even an exploding bunker that tops the list of scary things lurking around the TNT. No, it gets a lot stranger than that.
“The TNT Area itself is just chock full of amazing weirdness,” says Kurt McCoy, author of “White Things: West Virginia’s Weird White Monsters.”
White Things are exactly what they sound like. They are indefinable creatures the color of ghosts, crisp tablecloths and pure driven snow. Such stories crop up all over the U.S., but McCoy says they are especially prevalent in West Virginia. Over the years, McCoy has amassed many tales of White Things.
Legend has it that a car full of women were making their way home after a family reunion through the TNT Area. There was snow on the ground and they crunched along the treacherous roads at just a few miles an hour. And that’s when Sheepsquatch stepped out of the woods.
“I ran across everything from something that was described as a huge stingray that was white, to an owl-type thing. The archetypal White Thing is shaped sort of like a badger with a bushy tail and ranges in size from a large dog to slightly larger than a person,” says McCoy. “There was a headless monster in Grafton which was white, but had seal-like skin. And then, of course, there’s the notorious Sheepsquatch.”
Sheepsquatch first reared his oblong head in the 1990s.
Legend has it that a car full of women were making their way home after a family reunion through the TNT Area. There was snow on the ground and they crunched along the treacherous roads at just a few miles an hour. And that’s when it stepped out of the woods.
“The witnesses described it as being seven to eight feet tall, covered in shaggy white hair with legs like a man,” says McCoy. “And they described the face as looking a bit long like a sheep and having horns like a ram’s.”
Sheepsquatch (as it would come to be called) froze when it spotted the car, then bolted into the woods. Taking a cue from the mysterious beast, the women also high-tailed it out of there as fast as the wintery conditions would allow.
It was not, McCoy allows, a “dramatic sighting.”
Over the years, McCoy has collected stories of other sightings that follow a familiar pattern. A miner spotted a big white, grey thing and declared it not to be an “animal” but wouldn’t go further than that. A motorist spotted an animal on a hillside with a long face that looked to be covered in rags, or perhaps shedding a winter coat. A hunter encountered a creature crouched by a river for a drink, with horns and what seem to be human hands. Encounters with Sheepsquatch, for the most part, seem to be tame and infrequent.
Sheepsquatch has no popular backstory, no tales of sheep and radioactive goo or experiments gone awry. In fact, the Sheepsquatch name is occasionally used as a blanket term for all things scary and white. Being a monster in Point Pleasant is sort of like being an aspiring actor in Los Angeles: there’s a lot of creatures clamoring for attention.
The TNT Area alone has been host to bigfoot and UFO sightings. But most famously, Point Pleasant is home to Mothman, the manlike creature with the wings of a moth and glowing red eyes who terrorized townspeople over several weeks during the late ’60s. The Mothman was the subject of numerous newspaper accounts was blamed for a deadly bridge collapse and was the subject of a popular book “The Mothman Prophesies” which in turn was made into a movie starring Richard Gere. Point Pleasant is home to a Mothman statue, museum and annual festival.
It’s not easy being a cryptid in Mothman’s shadow.
But Sheepsquatch did garner some brief notoriety in March 2013 when it was the subject of the first installation of a show called “Monsters and Mysteries in America” on Destination America. It’s the kind of show that features interviews with real people interspersed with fairly bare-bones re-enactments. A segment details the adventures of two friends, Ricky Joyce and Dakota Cheeks, who go on a weekend hunting trip in Kentucky where they encounter more than deer.
“It was tall, but kind of hunched over,” says Cheeks, of the creature they say menaced them. “It was big, it was white.”
He tells the camera that the animal was “at least” 9 feet tall and, that it released an “ungodly, gut-curling growl” and “came straight at us.”
“We saw Sheepsquatch, that’s what we saw,” he says with certainty. This was not the timid Sheepsquatch of tales past.
‘I like to stay open to the possibility of strange things out there. And Sheepsquatch is one of the stranger things I’ve heard of.”
The episode earned dings from both critics and cryptozoology enthusiasts.
“Sheepsquatch? Are you F*n kidding me with this crap?,” wrote one commenter on the website Bigfoot Buzz.
McCoy says this exposes a friction within the cryptozoology community.
“There are a lot of people who take paranormal investigation and cryptozoology very seriously,” he says. “They don’t like anything that seems goofy or strange or is obviously unnatural. Because what they’re pushing is that there are actual undiscovered animals out there.”
McCoy says there are lots of weird sightings out there that can’t be defined. There are similar monsters like Sheepsquatch all over the place: There’s the Maryland Goat Man and The Pope Lick Monster in Kentucky (part man, part goat, part sheep), for instance.
But McCoy also isn’t up nights, wondering if the evidence sticks.
“People ask me if I believe that things are real,” he says. “I go with, if you believe something than you’ve made up your mind abut it. And I’m really not looking to solve mysteries. I like that there are things in the world that just aren’t easily solved, that there are mysteries out there that we just don’t understand yet. So I like to stay open to the possibility of strange things out there. And Sheepsquatch is one of the stranger things I’ve heard of.”Related