Ode to an Heirloom
What’s the value of an old apple?
At the apple orchard where I used to work, autumn’s encroaching frenzy had the most unassuming harbinger. One day in early August, a ladder would appear in a solitary old tree by the driveway, followed in the apple barn by some crates of pale green apples striped with cotton candy pink. I never quite knew who put the ladder there and picked those apples, but it was the starting gun for a helter-skelter season of picking, sorting, juicing, and selling apples. We’d catch our breath around Christmas.
That lonely tree stood apart from the rest of the orchard—its companions had long since died—as a sentinel from a bygone era. It was the orchard’s only remaining Liveland Raspberry, which is not in fact a berry, but a variety of apple—named after its country of origin, a former Soviet province. If you’ve never heard of it, that’s because the Liveland Raspberry is one of more than 10,000 varieties of heirloom apple grown in the United States.
A mystique surrounds heirloom apples. Some people drive across state lines to seek out rare varieties; others dedicate their lives to preserving them. Their price reflects the mystique: At my local food co-op, the heirlooms are twice as expensive as the other apples. The word “heirloom” basically means “old,” but it’s taken on some broader, ethereal meaning to many people: novelty, obscurity, nostalgia, and maybe even superiority. For some people, heirlooms can ascend to become the object of a grail quest: the dream that we can bring the past back to life.
READ MORE
Learn how the resurgence of hard cider is restoring old apple orchards.
The irony in all this is that many heirloom apples aren’t actually that good. Take that lonely Liveland Raspberry: There was a reason the orchard was down to a single tree and more hadn’t been planted. Eaten out of hand, the Liveland’s texture is tough and its flavor is uninspiring. It’s better for cooking, but it’s still not as good as other apples in our August lineup. So, the Livelands generally withered in the cooler until some day in October, when we’d find them buried under a pile of crates and dump them all into the cider press. This was an annual tradition as consistent as the appearance of the phantom ladder. In this case, “heirloom” served as code for “relegated to history’s compost bin.”
Is there a way to peer through the ephemeral mist, to understand not only whether heirlooms are worth the hype, but what heirloom diehards are truly searching for?
I spoke with some growers who have devoted their lives to heirlooms to see if they could break the spell and help me understand the true value of an heirloom.
“I think an heirloom has to have a little bit more going for it” than just its age, says Dan Bussey, author of The Illustrated History of Apples in the United States and Canada, which catalogs and describes 16,350 varieties in seven volumes. “It needs to be something that had a life someplace—that was popular, people liked it. It has to have some value other than just being old.”
Interestingly, the value of an old apple can actually be its newness. I once sold apples to a couple who were looking for heirlooms. I offered them samples of such ancient varieties as Golden Russet, Wealthy, and Tolman Sweet, before they tried a Melba and fell in love. I tried to explain that Melbas, the product of a Canadian breeding program, were not technically heirlooms, but they had none of it. They had tasted mana and wanted five pounds, thank you very much.
That couple was using “heirloom” in a way that many people do, which is to mean “obscure.” So, there’s no small irony that one of the world’s most well-known apples, the McIntosh, easily meets any definition of an heirloom, having been discovered as a seedling by John McIntosh on his Ontario farm in 1811.
Many people know the McIntosh as a soft, mealy apple, and they despise it. Yet, there’s a small club of us for whom the Mac represents the archetypal apple. Imagine scouring a tree for an apple that’s hung on long enough to turn bright crimson, so ripe that it falls off right into your hand; biting into its crisp, snappy flesh, the juice’s tartness cutting through the last heat of summer, its incomparably rich flavor transporting you, if only for a moment, into reverie.
But blink, and you could miss that moment. The problem with the McIntosh, like many heirlooms, is that it doesn’t store particularly well. Within as little as a week or two after picking, a Mac may begin to lose its perfect crunch. And considering that the average apple on a supermarket shelf has been in storage for eight months, by the time your average apple-eater encounters a McIntosh, September’s sweet-sour snap has given way to the mealy mush of May. Today’s apples need to function in a system of international commerce, and they need to look presentable 12 months and 12,000 miles from their time and place of origin.
TAKE ACTION
Fall is the perfect time for gleaning. Learn more here.
The McIntosh has other traits that bedevil its growers—Macs bruise easily, are especially susceptible to the fungal disease Apple Scab, and tend to fall off the tree before they’re fully ripe. Modern apple breeding programs have worked to eliminate these nuisances.
When the needs of the grower and grocer eclipse those of the eater, then your supermarket apple boasts a bright, shiny skin that cloaks blandness and fatigue, and sends apple enthusiasts looking elsewhere.
However, if this sentiment becomes overblown, then heirlooms can become code for “snobbishly superior.” In this case, the apple’s worth is predicated on its rarity, which makes ubiquitous apples, like the McIntosh, inherently worthless.
I asked the orchardists I interviewed whether there were apple varieties that weren’t good enough to deserve preservation. C.J. Walke, who manages the Maine Heritage Orchard, believes that’s the wrong question to ask. Instead, it’s important to look at the function of heirlooms in a robust local food system and regional economy. “If we go back 100-plus years, a lot of these varieties were grown on the farm or on the homestead, and they served a purpose for that family’s needs,” says Walke. Some were sold, but many were consumed right there by the family, eaten fresh or preserved as applesauce, cider, or vinegar. Heirloom varieties are so numerous because each fits a niche for every particular farm family, in terms of flavor, function, seasonality, and cold tolerance.
When I asked the orchardists why customers come to them looking for heirlooms, the reason that came up again and again was nostalgia.
“Their grandma had this tree, or their parents had this tree, and they haven’t seen it in 40 years,” says Jamie Hanson, the orchard manager at Seed Savers Exchange. “And so, for them, it’s a very personal experience.”
The richness of those memories drives the orchardists’ passion for their work.
“What moves me is how many generations of people loved these varieties,” says Erin Robinson, Orchardist at Scott Farm, in Dummerston, Vermont. “I am a link in that chain. I feel like it’s my duty to preserve them.”
Indeed, there’s something about apples that makes us look towards the past. Heirlooms hold the promise that there was once a richness that has been lost in the glossy monotones of the supermarket, and a diversity that met each individual’s particular need.
What excites Dan Bussey about heirlooms is their specificity, that a person can find something that fits their exact tastes. “I like everything to be a democratic process, where we all get a chance to try something, and if we love it, we should share it,” he says. “We should make it available to anybody. And if we like growing old varieties, great. If we love growing new varieties, wonderful. It’s what you like. That’s the important thing.”
Follow us
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Want to republish a Modern Farmer story?
We are happy for Modern Farmer stories to be shared, and encourage you to republish our articles for your audience. When doing so, we ask that you follow these guidelines:
Please credit us and our writers
For the author byline, please use “Author Name, Modern Farmer.” At the top of our stories, if on the web, please include this text and link: “This story was originally published by Modern Farmer.”
Please make sure to include a link back to either our home page or the article URL.
At the bottom of the story, please include the following text:
“Modern Farmer is a nonprofit initiative dedicated to raising awareness and catalyzing action at the intersection of food, agriculture, and society. Read more at <link>Modern Farmer</link>.”
Use our widget
We’d like to be able to track our stories, so we ask that if you republish our content, you do so using our widget (located on the left hand side of the article). The HTML code has a built-in tracker that tells us the data and domain where the story was published, as well as view counts.
Check the image requirements
It’s your responsibility to confirm you're licensed to republish images in our articles. Some images, such as those from commercial providers, don't allow their images to be republished without permission or payment. Copyright terms are generally listed in the image caption and attribution. You are welcome to omit our images or substitute with your own. Charts and interactive graphics follow the same rules.
Don’t change too much. Or, ask us first.
Articles must be republished in their entirety. It’s okay to change references to time (“today” to “yesterday”) or location (“Iowa City, IA” to “here”). But please keep everything else the same.
If you feel strongly that a more material edit needs to be made, get in touch with us at [email protected]. We’re happy to discuss it with the original author, but we must have prior approval for changes before publication.
Special cases
Extracts. You may run the first few lines or paragraphs of the article and then say: “Read the full article at Modern Farmer” with a link back to the original article.
Quotes. You may quote authors provided you include a link back to the article URL.
Translations. These require writer approval. To inquire about translation of a Modern Farmer article, contact us at [email protected]
Signed consent / copyright release forms. These are not required, provided you are following these guidelines.
Print. Articles can be republished in print under these same rules, with the exception that you do not need to include the links.
Tag us
When sharing the story on social media, please tag us using the following: - Twitter (@ModFarm) - Facebook (@ModernFarmerMedia) - Instagram (@modfarm)
Use our content respectfully
Modern Farmer is a nonprofit and as such we share our content for free and in good faith in order to reach new audiences. Respectfully,
No selling ads against our stories. It’s okay to put our stories on pages with ads.
Don’t republish our material wholesale, or automatically; you need to select stories to be republished individually.
You have no rights to sell, license, syndicate, or otherwise represent yourself as the authorized owner of our material to any third parties. This means that you cannot actively publish or submit our work for syndication to third party platforms or apps like Apple News or Google News. We understand that publishers cannot fully control when certain third parties automatically summarize or crawl content from publishers’ own sites.
Keep in touch
We want to hear from you if you love Modern Farmer content, have a collaboration idea, or anything else to share. As a nonprofit outlet, we work in service of our community and are always open to comments, feedback, and ideas. Contact us at [email protected].by John Ela, Modern Farmer
September 13, 2024
Modern Farmer Weekly
Solutions Hub
Innovations, ideas and inspiration. Actionable solutions for a resilient food system.
ExploreShare With Us
We want to hear from Modern Farmer readers who have thoughtful commentary, actionable solutions, or helpful ideas to share.
SubmitNecessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and are used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies.